Last Updated on September 4, 2020
The Many Signs of Jonah
- Jonah was sent to an ungodly people – That’s not who Brother Stair claims to be sent to
- Jonah ran from Gods calling – Brother Stair claims running from a woman prophetess [does that count]
- Jonah’s audience repented – Something Brother Stair says his audience does not do and that his generations will not do
- Jonah’s audience was spared by God – Something Brother Stair claims is not going to happen to his
- Jonah’s prophecy failed, making him a false prophet (Deut 18:20-22) – something Brother Stair claims his have not and he is not – Yet likewise, all his prophecies have failed [but who’s counting]
- Jonah was bitter and complaining and wanted his audience to be judged and distorted – That would be the same for Brother Stair [he won that one]
The Changing Sign
So we see that where Brother Stair is the same sign as Jonah is in being a prophet who ran from God’s call and ended up a bitter complainer wishing destruction upon his audience even after his prophecy failed, which then made him a false prophet.
Jesus referenced Jonah’s three days and nights in the belly of a fish as a representing sign of the length of His death and burial – three days and three nights. This is the only part of Jonah that Jesus spoke of as a sign – the time frame of Jesus’ burial. This does not have anything to do with Brother Stair’s “Jonah Sign” which he claims to be the fulfillment of. Yet the sign of His death and resurrection is the only sign Jesus spoke of regarding Jonah. Seems like someone is after making themselves into every kind of Sign they can. There’s something psychologically wrong there, but that is the pattern of those with the Jerusalem Syndrome.
The False Sign
The disciples came unto Him privately, saying,
Tell us, when shall these things be?
and what shall be the sign of Thy coming, and of the end of the world?
When Brother Stair starts you on this journey with him of The Sign of Jonah he starts in Matthew 24 so that he can get the disciples asking Him what will be the sign of the End? Then, without giving us Jesus’ answer [which we have at the end of this article] Brother Stair jumps back to Matthew 12 where the Pharisees are now asking a different question (Brother Stair doesn’t tell you that) and he gives us Jesus’ answer there because He mentions a sign – but it’s not a sign of the End it’s a sign of His authority.
Then some of the scribes and Pharisees said to Him,
“Teacher, we want to see a sign (attesting miracle) from You [proving that You are what You claim to be].” (Mt 12:38 AMP)
What’s more, is that Jesus tells them in Matthew 12 that an evil and adulterous generation looks for a sign and none will be given it. Yet we have Brother Stair proudly proclaiming himself as the sign given to an evil and adulterous generation (as he teaches this generation to be). Jesus said that the only sign that will be given the evil and adulterous generation is this, His sign – of His death and resurrection (Mt 12:39-40). There is no Jonah Sign showing the Time of the End or some Last Day Prophet. That has been totally fabricated by Brother Stair to teach that he is Some Great One (Acts 8:9). It’s nowhere in scripture and he has to jump around, as a Jehovah’s Witness does, just to even make it say what he makes it say – what it doesn’t say.
Portrait of a False Prophet
No one with any knowledge of scripture or with any sense would not go around claiming Jonah upon myself – and neither did Jesus. Brother Stair uses the sign of Jonah in his own way – not what Jesus said Jonah’s sign was. Bro Stair changes it to, as Jonah was sent to Nineveh… Then proclaiming that as such Brother Stair is sent to this last generation. Thus becoming like Jonah, thus making him also a false prophet and the fact that Bro Stair’s prophecies have all failed is likely much the reason he takes up the mantle of Jonah to find justification in his failed prophecy.
You can hear Brother Stair do this in some of his TV interviews back around 1987 where he refuted them calling him a false prophet with, “Was Jonah a false prophet? Did his prophecy fail?” The problem here is the assumption that Jonah was a prophet whose prophecy failed yet was a true prophet. Even those countering Brother Stair on this program are under this assumption, like most of the Church. But the word of God tells us that such a prophet is a false prophet (Deut 18:20-22). Just because Jonah is in the Bible doesn’t disqualify him as a false prophet. His prophecy failed, therefore he’s a false prophet (Deut 18:20-22). Having actually spoken what God told him (if he did) does not disqualify the test that God laid down in scripture. Is Balaam or Jezebel a true prophet just because they are in the Bible? Or is the scripture not true that says, “You destroy all who are unfaithful to You”? (Ps 73:27) Remember Jonah was unfaithful to God’s call. Jonah was destroyed from being a prophet to God’s people.
The Unfaithful Sign
Perhaps Brother Stair is thinking of himself as a Jonah sign in how he (unfaithfully) went to California against God’s will and tells us that Prophet Thorn was sent to him to tell him to repent and return. Something that Brother Stair refused to do for a long time. When he finally did start back east (likely due to his failure in the west) he only then eased himself back, with stops in Oklahoma – where he was arrested and went to trial on groping a minor (or as he calls it today – hugging). Or we could go back to the beginning when he was told about his first marriage that God’s not in this. Or his choosing to be schooled by the wicked rather than by a Christian institution (Pr 1:10; 2:12; 5:8, 10, 22-23).
Brother Stair has used Jonah as a defense from the beginning when his 1988 Prophecies failed and were challenged. Knowing they failed he would come back at his questioners asking them, “Jonah’s prophecy failed. Was Jonah a false prophet?” Brother Stair was clearly admitting that his prophecies had failed in the 1988 prophecy. He didn’t try weaseling out of it as he has over the past decades since saying, they have all come to pass or that they are about to come to pass. Soon after 1988 Brother Stair and everyone else knew that what he said had in no way come to pass and time had run out for it to have – how many times did he say “this year”? So the Jonah defense was used. Since then Jonah has been branded into the sign of Jonah. “As Jonah was sent to Nineveh…”
But this defense would then be an acknowledgment by Brother Stair that his prophecies have failed. So, it seems that Brother Stair has is both ways:
- His prophecies have failed – but so did Jonah’s and he was still a true prophet [Not so]. Another cop-out is that he’s never said anything Thus Saith the Lord.
- Everything Brother Stair has prophesied has come to pass. [I think he forgot that he dated the fulfillment of most of those things, especially that were to take place before 1987 ended.]
Now having it both those ways is some kinda miracle – perhaps it’s a sign after all.
Apparently, Brother Stair is saying here that he comes with a word of coming destruction that is not going to come to pass. Then he is going to go up to a high place (airwaves) and complain about it and every other inconvenience that besets him. A grumbling complaining bitter man whining to God about how inconvenienced his life is by the continued existence of those he’s preached to, upon whom he wishes destruction so that his words would come true. Okay, I’ll give you that, that is fitting here.
The True Sign of The End
In Brother Stair’s jumping about to make himself out to be some great one (Acts 8:9) he forgot to actually tell you Jesus’ answer to His disciples in Matthew 24 in regards to their question. You know, the question that Brother Stair uses to base all this upon. It’s very important to note this because the answer Jesus gives as the sign of thy coming, and of the end of the world (Mt 24:3) is of the utmost importance today.
Jesus answered, “Be careful that no one misleads you [deceiving you and leading you into error]. For many will come in My name [misusing it, and appropriating the strength of the name which belongs to Me], saying, ‘I am the Christ (the Messiah, the Anointed),’ and they will mislead many. (Mt 24:4 AMP)
That’s not the sign that I would be making myself out to be. But it is certainly the sign of Brother Stair.
Let us not forget God’s reply to Jonah. God was more concerned with the ‘godless’ generations that Jonah condemned to destruction then He was with the Prophet or his whining. Let’s also not forget that scripture tells us that God is the same – yesterday, today, forever (Heb 13:8).
What think ye?